BOOK TALK: Are you too honest with reviews?

As readers, we should understand at this point that book reviews absolutely mean everything to new authors and generally, all authors. Without reviews, authors will not be able to spread the good news of their books they worked so hard on and receive the pretty pay check they are essentially working for.

As an ARC reviewer and a book reviewer of many books printed by Indie authors and New York Times Bestsellers, I know that my reviews are straight from the heart with sometimes very few censors. I swear. A lot. I get excited. Many times. And yes, I get angry and disappointed and frustrated a lot too.

I believe I’m being fair with most reviews, expressing my concerns with characters and their development, advancement in plot, and overall the story itself. I even add in my reviews a recommendation to my readers to let them know the bottom line. Should you pay for the book or should you pass it up.

Often, I find myself being lenient with authors. I suggest to read other books prior to the one I’m reviewing if I didn’t really like it or I suggest my readers to read the books after some others.

Like I said before, I work with a lot of indie authors now. These authors are self-published or just starting their careers as writers, promoting their first published novels through big influencers so that their work they worked so hard on won’t go unnoticed. My reviews alongside with everyone else’s on Goodreads and Amazon will help promote the novel as well as take them down a notch. And because authors understand this concept, there’s a lot of things happening right now with review culture.

Image result for book reader illustration tumblr

  1. Being too nice.

An author contacted you or replied back to your request for an ARC. You’re beyond excited and you feel like you’re finally closer to the author that you’ve heard so much about or even, it’s an author you’ve really admired from a long time ago. However, when you read the actual piece, it doesn’t live up to your standards, causing you to feel disappointed. The remaining problem? You feel obligated to give them a glowing review or a review that paints the picture of the book better than it appears to be simply because they went through the effort to give you a copy or even send you a loot box to promote it.

The problem with this should be obvious. You’re doing the author, readers, and yourself a disservice by not giving an honest review. It’s like buying a kitchen appliance and having it not work really well but you still give it a 5/5 star rating on Amazon because you feel bad since it’s from a small company that just started out. By giving a fluffed review, the author has an inflated ego, believing their world building, character creations, and much more are perfect. They don’t need to improve key weaknesses in their writing, allowing them to continue down the same path, never improving. And when they finally receive an honest review, they’re shocked because they’ve surrounded themselves with so many ego boosters that they think the person writing it is purposely being negative towards them.

Related image

      2. Focusing on the negatives

On the other hand, I have to admit I am guilty of being too honest sometimes. I vent. A lot. And it comes out pretty negative since I will admit I focus on a lot of things that did bother me.I understand that my vents will leave a negative impression for a lot of my readers and may affect the sales of their books. However, I try to be very truthful with it. I’m not going to purposely slander a novel because of spite. That goes against my core and I always give novels a chance.

Don’t be one of those reviewers who haven’t actually read the book and just give one star reviews because of what you’ve heard. It’s like someone that is judging you based on rumors in the office. It’s not fair for the author and the book. And who knows? You might actually like the book you “hated” so much.

Image result for book reader illustration tumblr

       3. Filter, Filter, Filter.

Another thing I noticed about authors? They like to filter their reviews. Do you have a less than 3 star rating for their latest review? Chances are, your review will no longer be tagged with them. I’m seriously not joking. I dealt with a lot of indie authors who know that negative reviews impact sales so they block you, delete the tag, or do whatever they need to do so that they can limit the audience of your review. It’s something that not a lot of people are aware of and just assume never happens.

Can you even imagine how many reviews out there that were blocked? You would just assume that everyone loved it but in reality, everything is just censored.

On the other hand, authors are humans too. We forget that authors can see what we post and everything in between. It affects their well-being and can encourage or discourage them as writers. They have been suffering a low point in their lives and your review was just a cherry on top to their awfulness. So to be fair, if someone is being particularly nasty and their reviews are unjustified and overly critical, it is no surprise that the review may be removed just so that authors can keep their sanity and confidence in themselves and their work.

Image result for book gifs

In conclusion…

My remaining takeaway as a reviewer? Be honest but also understand both sides to everything. Justify your points in your review instead of just attacking at everything. Help the author learn from their past. Help the readers decided what to read. Don’t be too overly critical. And as for authors, understand that reviews don’t mean that we hate you.

It’s nothing personal. We may love the next idea you have in your head that has yet been written or we may have loved your previous ideas but this one just fell short.

Related image


22 thoughts on “BOOK TALK: Are you too honest with reviews?

    1. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this one! And definitely, whether we need to improve on our reviews or just tone it down a bit, it’s an important issue in the bookish community.


  1. “Help the author learn from their past. Help the readers decided what to read.”

    I think this is sort of the golden rule, if you will, of writing book reviews. No one is entitled to a glowing review; it must be earned.

    The vast majority of what I read will get median ratings on my blog because they were good, but nothing spectacular or new. For the few that fall below, I usually find something to venerate within the review despite focusing on the issues within the novel for most of the post (unintentional rhyme but I’m not deleting it).

    This was a wonderful post and I enjoyed reading it!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this post and commenting on it!!!

      I think you’re right in many ways as well to focus on the good instead of just focusing on the bad. As a reviewer of a relatively small blog (I have 352 followers), I have to realize that no matter how small, my reviews will be read at some point if the scope is within the limits.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This was a very insightful read. As both a reviewer and an aspiring author thank you for putting it up!! I’m curious as well, how do you become an ARC reviewer? Did you contact the authors directly or go through a publishing company? Thanks so much,
    (Aka bookmarks and dogears) 👍🏼


  3. This is a great article! I got some books from the author myself and she is so nice! but I started reading the first book and it’s so bad.. I feel like even giving it 3 stars will be too much but I don’t also want to be mean.. It’s not like I’m payed to write that review and she sent me books herself.. so I’m very indesicive about my review😔


    1. Try to do what others and myself are trying to do by giving pros and cons and justify your reasonings for why you may feel the way you do. Use less critical language as well to help soften the blow! I look forward to reading it Kate!


  4. I love this post and I so understand what you’re saying. As a reviewer I am going to be honest but when writing the review I tend to list out a few points on both pros and cons of the book. I’m not afraid to criticize but I will always provide a reason why. At the end of the day everyone has a different opinion about a book. I know that if I didn’t like it all that much that chances are someone else will love it. At the end of the day honesty is the best policy.


  5. Omg it’s like you read my mind! I’m currently having the struggle of reading a book that a recived from a publisher which I’m having some issues with and I don’t know whether or not I should keep reading and do a review, even if it might be bad, or just stop reading. Especially since the publishing company I received the book from want me to email them the links for where I mentioned the book. This post really helped, but if you could give me some extra help they would be amazing xx

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hey there!Thank you for taking the time to comment on this blog post and also reading it. Honestly, the past reviewer in me would tell you to go with your heart and don’t waste your time on books that seriously make you angry. However, after venting and seeing both sides of the story, I decided to switch to being a more fair of a reviewer. Even if i hate the story or I just wasn’t connecting with it, I try to mention a few good things I did enjoy about it–unless I completely hate everything. If this is a major publishing company, it’s not that bad if you give less than a 3 star review in my opinion because they have better press coverage and marketing to help outshine your lacklustre review. However, if it’s indie, it might be a little harder since they have a limited audience and reviews really matter. They usually then only emphasize on three star and above reviews and I even had a lot of companies that told me to not put up a review if it’s less than 3 stars. I know. It’s a form of censorship. But it’s part of the agreement I go through when I request.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s